The prototype for the modern mastermind detective, holmes first appeared in conan doyles a study in scarlet, published in beetons christmas annual of 1887. The 10 best sherlock holmes movies of all time posted on march 20, 2016 march 20, 2016 by george cromack having been portrayed on screen in excess of two hundred and fifty times, producing any list of film titles featuring sir arthur conan doyles sherlock holmes who first appeared in print in 1887 is no easy task. This story is also included in the list of sir arthur conan doyles favorite stories. Its codethemed story probably inspired by edgar allan poes the goldbug, the dancing men is one of holmess greatest codebreaking triumphs. With basil rathbone, nigel bruce, lionel atwill, kaaren verne. Top now that you know the best sherlock holmes stories, be sure to read about the 10 most famous quotations from the holmes stories, the best basil rathbone holmes movies and.
Jan 02, 2017 new years day this year had the series premiere of sherlock series 4 on bbc with 8. But as with the original story, while the mystery was engrossing, the. Prowling the underworld as a detective in adaptations for films, radio and television, the detective boston blackie. Its been a raucous ride hanging out with sherlock holmes benedict. Sherlock went from supersleuth to the baker street men. Watson by playing him as an old buffoon starred in a staggering 14 films for 20th. I am particularly interested in any ballots from the 1944 1959 polls and in story scores from the 1989 sherlock holmes journal poll that were not published in the shj.
Having read all the original holmes stories, i absolutely agree with you, jeremy brett is holmes. List of sherlock holmes short stories and novels baker. Mar 20, 2016 the 10 best sherlock holmes movies of all time posted on march 20, 2016 march 20, 2016 by george cromack having been portrayed on screen in excess of two hundred and fifty times, producing any list of film titles featuring sir arthur conan doyles sherlock holmes who first appeared in print in 1887 is no easy task. Sherlock holmes and doctor watson must protect a swiss inventor of an advanced bomb sight from falling into german hands. Most popular sherlock holmes movies and tv shows imdb. The 12 best sherlock holmes stories, according to arthur. In an adaptation of arthur conan doyles most famous sherlock holmes story, the hounds of baskerville sent sherlock and john to fight ghosts and hallucinations.
Now that story is coming to a close, and its time to celebrate elementary as the best sherlock holmes adaptation to date. Arguably the actor most commonly identified with sherlock holmes on film, sir basil rathbone made 14 sherlock holmes movies between 1939 and 1946, creating the. The detective has appeared onscreen over 250 times in total. Perhaps bestknown for holmess famous line about the curious incident of the dog in the nighttime used by mark haddon as the title for his bestselling novel, silver blaze is the first story in the second collection of classic sherlock holmes stories, the memoirs of sherlock holmes 1893. Given the characters haughty demeanor and his ability to solve even the most baffling cases, its clear to see why so many fans and fellow writers like to take potshots at him. I adore the granada series, and ive spent enough time introducing it to friends that ive developed a private list of episodes to use for that purpose. Can you sort these sherlock episodes into their respective seasons. The 10 best sherlock holmes movies of all time taste of. In fact, sherlock holmes is the most played literary human character in history according to the guinness book of world records. The most famous holmes story can be a tricky one to get right on screen itvs 1988 version from the otherwise superb jeremy brett series is.
Arthur conan doyle names his 19 favorite sherlock holmes. So, in the spirit of appreciation, ive put together a short list of a few of my favorites. His reach extends beyond the success of holmesian tv sherlock and elementary and film 2009s sherlock holmes and the upcoming mr. Sherlock holmes, fictional character created by the scottish writer arthur conan doyle. Whether films and series interpret the existing stories, or use them as a departure point for new episodes that seem in line with holmes and watsons adventures bbcs sherlock has done a good job of that, doyles stories are still the source. They asked conan doyle the same question, and the list he came up with runs as. Those who are fortunate enough to not already know the ending before reading will find it very gratifying. Sherlock holmes story rankings from all polls the best of. Every single episode ranked from worst to best metro news. Sherlocks mark gatiss teases absolutely crazy series 4 finale. New years day this year had the series premiere of sherlock series 4 on bbc with 8. Are the sherlock holmes books good and worth reading.
As originally created by author jack boyle, he was a safecracker, a hardened criminal who had served time in a california prison. Sir arthur conan doyle, the creator of the character sherlock holmes released his 12 favourite sherlock holmes stories to the strand magazine in 1927. Viewers from around the world have been asked which bbc character they love the most, and each of the top three is one of our favorites. The chemistry between irene and sherlock is so intense. Adapted from conan doyles original stories and novels, sherlock holmes jeremy brett, one of the worlds greatest and most popular fictional detectives, investigates baffling cases. Created by steven moffat and mark gatiss, it stars benedict cumberbatch as sherlock holmes and martin freeman as doctor john watson. Baskervilles is a weird story in the totality of the holmes cannon, but as far as following the formula of the scariest sherlock tales, all of the best and most effective devices are employed, but. The hound made doyle a fortune in 1901, and is still making. Sherlock holmes and pc andrew burke investigate the case of a blackmailer holding an entire apartment block to ransom. May 22, 2018 as peter haining, editor of the final adventures of sherlock holmes, the collection of holmesrelated artifacts and ephemera from which i have sourced conan doyles strand essays, has pointed out, after this essay, conan doyle never wrote another word about his most famous creation.
Of all the holmes stories 56 short stories and four novels in all one of the most popular is the hound of the baskervilles. With 24 episodes per season, by the end of season two miller became the actor who had portrayed sherlock holmes the most in television andor film. All 9 sherlock episodes ranked by you sherlocks home. Dont get me started on that travesty they call the. Here are the top picks, found for you through careful ab testing. No less than 78 different actors have taken their turn at portraying the enigmatic deduction machine in various mediums, and each has brought their own foibles to the role. Elementary was the best sherlock holmes adaptation screen rant. Jan 06, 2014 12 best sherlock holmes stories handpicked by creator sir arthur conan doyle bbcs sherlock season 3 debuted on january 1 with the first episode drawing from the empty house short story. Benedict himself told the bbc he was honored his portrayal of sherlock holmes had come out on top, saying. Lippincotts monthly magazine featuring the sign of the four. This was published in 1890 in lippincotts monthly magazine. Deducing the timeless popularity of sherlock holmes cbs news. Aug 14, 2019 now that story is coming to a close, and its time to celebrate elementary as the best sherlock holmes adaptation to date.
Jan 19, 2014 of all the holmes stories 56 short stories and four novels in all one of the most popular is the hound of the baskervilles. Sherlock holmes adventures podcast listen via stitcher. Monk was the decades silliestand saddestsherlock holmes. This story is so good, though, that it can be read multiple times with the same level of enjoyment as the first. This was published in 1887 in beetons christmas annual. Sherlock holmes is among the most ubiquitous characters of all time. While gillette may have been the best allaround actor to ever portray holmes, rathbone, a south african by birth but an englishman by parentage, was the most popular.
James moriarty, considered as the only real enemy that sherlock holmes ever faced. The 5 scariest sherlock holmes stories for halloween. Just how many sherlock holmes novels and short stories are there. Between 1939 and 1946, rathbone and nigel bruce who did untold damage to the legacy of dr. The story is a simplified version of the adventure of the redheaded league, but wilson is a. Elementary didnt take sherlock holmes seriously key to elementary is the fact that the show doesnt take sherlock holmes too seriously something sir arthur conan doyle himself would have approved of.
It was quite layered, and pretty much all through, it comes across as a story rooted in legend rather than a traditional my. Hilton cubitt of ridling thorpe manor in norfolk, and husband to a nervous wife, tells holmes a series of stick figures have started. Perhaps bestknown for holmes s famous line about the curious incident of the dog in the nighttime used by mark haddon as the title for his bestselling novel, silver blaze is the first story in the second collection of classic sherlock holmes stories, the memoirs of sherlock holmes 1893. The novel series written by sir arthur conan doyle, is one of the most recreated than any other work of art in history, including the guinness world record for most portrayed human movie character, with more than 70 actors playing the part in over 200 films. Return to the best sherlock holmes stories summary page. Jan 17, 2017 series 4 of sherlock has garnered some fairly mixed reactions, and this opener was most coolly received, largely for its impenetrably knotty narrative and a brutal death of a main character at the. The first two episodes of season three spent most of their running time on farce, pranks and hijinks, including sherlock disguising himself as a waiter before revealing his return to watson, and. Most popular reference to sherlock holmes movies and. Sherlock is a crime television series that presents a contemporary adaptation of sir arthur conan doyles sherlock holmes detective stories. Irene adler is a formidable opponent for holmes and is an unusually strong and independent female character for the time period albeit not an unwelcome one.
Sherlock, portrayed by robert stephens, is full of witticisms. Doyle himself considered it the third best sherlock holmes story of the lot. Instead, we got most of her backstory and characterization stuffed into one episode, which made. Arthur conan doyles most famous sherlock holmes tale became a. Sherlock named the worlds most popular bbc character. Certainly the bestknown story in the holmes canon, any adaptation of the hounds of baskerville was bound to come under more scrutiny than others. Readers loved it, magazine sales soared, and conan doyle would go on to publish a total of 4 novels and 56 short stories about. Sherlock holmes is over years old, which means there are quite a few interpretations of the famed detective out there, especially on screen. Listen to sherlock holmes adventures podcast episodes free, on demand. Minnie omalley, a cowgirl in bison jacks visiting rodeo show, seeks help. A study in scarlet is an 1887 detective novel by scottish author arthur conan doyle.
As we learned in the most recent episode of sherlock, emotional context. Sherlock holmes is one of the most famous characters in modern history, and has appeared in film more often than any other character. You would expect this episode to be more popular, what with it being the most wellknown original sherlock holmes story. You might consider reading the adventures of sherlock holmes according to the preferences of sherlock holmes creator. The books title derives from a speech given by holmes, a consulting detective, to his friend and chronicler watson on the. Dec, 2019 sherlock holmes is over years old, which means there are quite a few interpretations of the famed detective out there, especially on screen. In june of 1891, a scandal in bohemia, the first short story featuring everyones favorite consulting detective sherlock holmes, was published in the strand magazine.
Basil, the rodent sherlock holmes, investigates the kidnapping of a toy maker and uncovers its link to his archenemy, professor ratigan. Arguably the actor most commonly identified with sherlock holmes on film, sir basil rathbone made 14 sherlock holmes movies between 1939 and 1946, creating the deerstalker and cape look in the. This website includes other top 10 lists for the best sherlock holmes gifts, the best basil rathbone movies, the best holmes quotes, and more. The enduring popularity of sherlock holmes sherlock holmes is 124 years old and hes never been in such high demand. Which are the best sherlock holmes jeremy brett episodes. The woman, sherlock, their chemistry, the whole story and the way it boils down is just too good. Is sherlock holmes the most popular fictional character of. Boston blackie is a fictional character who has been on both sides of the law. When is benedict cumberbatch at his most cumberbatchian. Its been a raucous ride hanging out with sherlock holmes benedict cumberbatch. Sara bruni, tony carpenter, lewis davis, tamzin dunstone. Holmes is called to a manor house to investigate the brutal murder of a country lord with a fireplace poker and reconcile the story of his bruised and battered wife with the facts.
In terms of sheer numbers, sherlock holmes seems to be the one to beat hes the current holder of the guinness world record for the most portrayed literary character across film and television. Scotland yard comes to sherlock with a curious case involving a cabinet ministers son and smashed statues of late prime minister margaret thatcher. Jul 31, 2015 all the depictions of how sherlock did it though without a definitive answer and a new dynamic as mary steps into the fray that sets the stage for the rest of the series. The hound of the baskervilles it was the first holmes story i read when i was young, and the one that i liked the most. The fourth installment finds sherlock waiting for a presumably dead moriartys next move as watson and mary take on new roles as firsttime parents. Is charles augustus magnussen more intelligent than sherlock holmes.
All the depictions of how sherlock did it though without a definitive answer and a new dynamic as mary steps into the fray that sets the stage for the rest of the series. Sherlock is a british crime television series based on sir arthur conan doyles sherlock holmes detective stories. This is somewhat surprising, really, considering it is based off the most famous sherlock holmes story ever. Apr 04, 2012 whether films and series interpret the existing stories, or use them as a departure point for new episodes that seem in line with holmes and watsons adventures bbcs sherlock has done a good job of that, doyles stories are still the source. Heres a list that includes the date they were published. The story marks the first appearance of sherlock holmes and dr. Oct 28, 2016 baskervilles is a weird story in the totality of the holmes cannon, but as far as following the formula of the scariest sherlock tales, all of the best and most effective devices are employed, but. The private life of sherlock holmes 1970 billy wilders take on sherlock holmes is predictably comedic and absurdand much more. Vincent price, barrie ingham, val bettin, susanne pollatschek. When youve watched all the sherlock episodes to date, theres only one.
Elementary was the best sherlock holmes adaptation. Series 4 of sherlock has garnered some fairly mixed reactions, and this opener was most coolly received, largely for its impenetrably knotty narrative and. This modernday reboot has arthur conan doyles deductive genius moving through london as a webadept consultant to inspector lestrade. We know these preferences because of a 1927 competition in the strand magazine, where the characters popularity first blew up, which asked readers to name the twelve best sherlock holmes stories. A study in scarlet and the sign of the four, both novels, had already been printed elsewhere. Referring to himself as a consulting detective in the stories, holmes is known for his proficiency with observation, deduction, forensic science, and logical reasoning that borders on the fantastic, which he employs when. Were counting down the top five episodes of sherlock ever. Top 5 sherlock holmes stories you need to read nai. A scandal in bohemia this is the first sherlock holmes short story ever published and one of the most popular. Its part parody and part homage, concerned with the disparity between the holmes of real life and the holmes of watsons stories. Ron clements, burny mattinson, david michener, john musker stars. Holmes starred ian mckellen as a retired sherlock holmes living in sussex, in 1947, who grapples with an unsolved case involving a beautiful woman. Feb 15, 2016 this is the first sherlock holmes short story ever published and one of the most popular.
He just gets him to a tee, exactly was he was in the books, nobody else comes close, except maybe basil rathbone. Can you choose whether each given title is associated with a story starring sherlock holmes, perry mason or the hardy boys. Best sherlock episodes and the worst ranked by you radio times. Sherlockians from around the world selected the best sherlock holmes stories in the largest and most comprehensive survey ever conducted. One of the few episodes where granada altered the acd story and it worked handsomely. He was so popular that his own author couldnt kill him off, and hes remained a colossal cultural figure since. A woman in pink is the fourth in a series of seemingly unrelated suicides, but sherlock holmes deduces that the deaths are actually murders most. Watson, who would become the most famous detective duo in popular fiction. The books title derives from a speech given by holmes, a consulting detective, to his friend and chronicler watson on the nature of his work, in which he describes the story. Oddly, this turns out to be the least of their problems. The adventures of sherlock holmes 19841985, the return of sherlock holmes 19861988, the casebook of sherlock holmes 19911993 and the memoirs of sherlock holmes 1994, collectively known as sherlock holmes, are a series of adaptations of arthur conan doyles sherlock holmes stories which were produced by granada television and originally broadcast by itv in the united kingdom. As the worlds first and only consulting detective, he pursued criminals throughout victorian and edwardian london, the south of england. As with most popular characters past and present, sherlock holmes has frequently been the subject of ridicule. Most popular reference to sherlock holmes movies and tv.
1502 1112 1572 768 367 1355 734 978 299 1253 809 1293 969 1023 1556 80 302 1491 769 921 585 1033 1340 414 344 768 484 1062 1073 1083